top of page

Choosing a KPI: A Strategic Approach

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are vital tools for measuring progress and success in any business or project. However, selecting the right KPI is not a one-size-fits-all process; it’s a nuanced decision that requires careful consideration.

Many Digital and e-commerce teams will use Conversion Rate as a primary KPI to measure the effectiveness of sales and marketing efforts. This may not always be the most useful metric.

This is because:

  • It doesn’t account for the quality or value of each conversion. For example, a high conversion rate could be driven by low-value transactions that don’t significantly contribute to profitability.

  • It can overlook other important factors such as customer satisfaction, brand perception, and long-term customer value.

  • It is susceptible to fluctuations caused by external factors such as an increase in low converting traffic, market trends or seasonal changes

All of these factors may cause conversion rate to not reflect the actual performance of the business.

While conversion rate can provide insights, it should be considered alongside other KPIs that offer a more comprehensive view of business health and success.

Here’s a guide to help you choose a KPI that aligns with your goals and responsibilities.

It Depends

The most appropriate KPI for your situation depends on various factors, including your industry, the specific area of your business you wish to measure, and your strategic objectives. There’s no universal KPI suitable for all scenarios, so it’s essential to analyze your unique situation before deciding.

Sphere of Control > Concern

Focus on what you can control rather than what concerns you. While many factors can influence your business, effective KPIs should measure the aspects within your sphere of control. If your KPI is outside of your sphere of control, then your team is more of a "fan" of the KPI - rooting from the sidelines for it to grow - instead of a sole factor in its growth. Focusing on KPIs in your sphere of control ensures that you’re tracking metrics that reflect your direct actions and decisions.

Removes External Events/Forces

A well-chosen KPI should be insulated from external events and forces as much as possible. This isolation allows for a clearer assessment of performance, free from the noise of uncontrollable external factors. When considering a KPI, think about whether this number could rise or fall due to external events - if the answer is no, then you're on the right track.

Reflects Your Scope of Work, but Contributes to Larger Goal

Your KPI should mirror your scope of work while also contributing to the broader organizational goals. It’s crucial to ensure that your KPI is not only relevant to your immediate tasks but also feeds into the larger objectives of your company.

Look for a Problem, Construct a Solution, Use a KPI to Measure

Identify a problem area within your scope, devise a solution, and then select a KPI to track the effectiveness of your solution. This problem-solving approach ensures that your KPI has a clear purpose and provides actionable insights.

Choosing the right KPI is a strategic exercise that can significantly impact the effectiveness of your performance measurement. By considering the factors mentioned above, you can select a KPI that provides valuable insights, drives improvement, and aligns with your business objectives. Remember, the goal is not just to have a KPI but to have the right KPI that propels your business forward. Reach out to Zilker Trail Consulting today to discuss choosing the right KPIs. and how we can help grow those KPIs.

Related video: Choosing a KPI

Related video: Why Conversion Rate Is a Bad Metric

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page